📄 India’s Energy Security – Renewables vs Fossil Fuels

📄 India’s Energy Security – Renewables vs Fossil Fuels

📝 Introduction: Energy as the New Battlefield

In today’s world, energy security is national security. For India—the world’s fastest-growing large economy and the third-largest energy consumer—the ability to secure uninterrupted, affordable, and sustainable energy is a strategic priority.

  • India imports 85% of crude oil, 50% of natural gas, and nearly 25% of coal.
  • With a population of 1.4 billion and rising middle class, energy demand is expected to double by 2040.
  • Defence preparedness too is deeply tied to energy: fighter jets, submarines, tanks—all need fossil fuels.

At the same time, India has committed to Net Zero emissions by 2070, with an ambitious milestone of 500 GW renewable energy capacity by 2030.

Thus, India faces a strategic dilemma: Should it rely on fossil fuels for stability or rapidly shift to renewables for sustainability?

📊 India’s Current Energy Mix (2023 Snapshot)

(Source: Ministry of Power, NITI Aayog, IEA)

  • Coal: ~55% of power generation
  • Oil & Gas: ~30% of energy consumption
  • Renewables (Solar, Wind, Hydro, Biomass): ~12%
  • Nuclear: ~2%

India is still largely fossil-fuel dependent, but renewable capacity is growing at 22% CAGR (compound annual growth rate)—among the fastest globally.

⚡ Fossil Fuels – The Double-Edged Sword

✅ Advantages

  1. Reliable Base Load: Coal provides round-the-clock power, unlike solar & wind which are weather-dependent.
  2. Economic Growth: Fossil fuels are cheaper in short term; switching fully to renewables could raise power tariffs.
  3. Defence Imperative: Fossil fuels run fighter jets, warships, submarines, tanks—renewables cannot replace them immediately.
  4. Employment: Millions employed in coal mining, oil refining, transport.

⚠️ Risks

  1. Import Dependency: Oil imports = ~$160–180 billion annually (20% of total imports).
  2. Geopolitical Vulnerability: Middle East conflicts, Russia-Ukraine war, OPEC decisions directly hit India’s economy.
  3. Climate Impact: India is the 4th largest carbon emitter globally. Air pollution costs economy ~$95 billion annually (3% of GDP).

🌞 Renewables – The Strategic Alternative

✅ Strengths

  1. Solar Revolution: Solar tariffs in India fell from ₹17/kWh (2010) to <₹2.5/kWh (2023)—cheaper than coal in many cases.
  2. Wind Energy: India has potential of 302 GW wind capacity, mostly in coastal states.
  3. Energy Independence: Every 1 GW of solar saves ~$500 million in oil imports annually.
  4. Climate Leadership: India is among few nations on track to meet Paris Agreement goals.

⚠️ Challenges

  1. Intermittency: Solar works only during day; wind is seasonal.
  2. Storage Costs: Lithium-ion batteries are expensive & imported (China controls 70% supply chain).
  3. Land Requirements: 1 MW solar = 5 acres land → large projects face displacement/environmental issues.

📌 Case Studies – Lessons from Real World

1. Germany’s Energy Crisis (2022):

  • Depended on Russia for 55% natural gas imports.
  • After Ukraine war, supply cut → energy prices skyrocketed.
  • Lesson for India: overdependence on imports is dangerous.

2. International Solar Alliance (ISA):

  • Launched by India with 120+ nations.
  • Projects worth $1.4 billion sanctioned.
  • Gave India a leadership role in global energy diplomacy.

3. Green Hydrogen Mission (2023):

  • Aim: 5 MMT production annually by 2030.
  • Will reduce fossil fuel imports by $12 billion annually.
  • Hydrogen-powered buses and naval vessels under trials.

4. Nuclear Power – France’s Model:

  • France gets 70% of its electricity from nuclear.
  • India currently at 2% nuclear, but aims to expand via indigenous reactors (Kudankulam, Kalpakkam).

📊 Data & Mathematical Snapshot

  • India’s annual oil import bill: $160–180 billion.
  • Coal imports (2023): ~200 MT, worth $25 billion.
  • Solar costs dropped by 80% in last decade.
  • Renewable capacity: 175 GW (2023), target 500 GW by 2030.
  • Every 1% improvement in energy efficiency saves India ~$4 billion annually.

⚖️ Hybrid Energy Model – The Balanced Path

Energy experts suggest India cannot swing fully to renewables immediately; instead, a hybrid transition is ideal:

  1. Short Term (2023–2030):
    • Coal remains backbone for stability.
    • Massive solar & wind push.
    • Strengthen oil reserves (India has only 74 days’ stock vs IEA norm of 90 days).
  2. Medium Term (2030–2050):
    • Expansion of nuclear & green hydrogen.
    • Hybrid systems (solar + battery storage).
  3. Long Term (2050–2070):
    • Hydrogen, nuclear fusion, futuristic fuels.
    • Near-complete fossil fuel phase-out.

🎯 Relevance for SSB Aspirants

  • Group Discussion (GD) Topics:
    • “Can India achieve energy security without fossil fuels?”
    • “Is renewable energy the new battlefield for global dominance?”
  • Lecturette Ideas:
    • “Energy Security as National Security”
    • “India’s Renewable Energy Transition – Challenges & Opportunities”
  • PI (Personal Interview) Questions:
    • “If you were Defence Minister, how would you ensure energy supply during wartime blockade?”
    • “Should India prioritise jobs in coal sector or growth in solar industry?”

🔑 OLQ Angle: SSB tests whether candidates can balance strategic foresight, logical reasoning, and empathy for human costs. Energy security is a perfect case study of this balance.

🌟 Conclusion

India’s energy journey is a tightrope walk:

  • Fossil fuels provide immediate reliability, but keep India import-dependent and vulnerable.
  • Renewables offer independence and sustainability, but need technology & infrastructure upgrades.

The answer lies in a balanced, phased approach—using coal & oil for short-term needs, while aggressively scaling renewables, nuclear, and hydrogen for the future.

For SSB aspirants, the takeaway is clear: National security is not just about soldiers and weapons—it is about the power that fuels them. A future officer must think not only of the battlefield but also of the energy lines that sustain it.

📘 Learn more about OLQs with our 03 month OLQ ebook. A self paced guide to prepare candidates in getting ready to face the challenges thrown at SSB.

Preparing for SSB isn’t just about reading current affairs; it’s about structuring your thoughts with clarity.

Our eBook “OLQ – The Ultimate SSB Preparation Guide” by SSBChampions.com includes:

  • Model GD transcripts on energy security.
  • Lecturette frameworks for renewable vs fossil debates.
  • Case study methods to present facts + analysis in interviews.

👉 Reading this blog + practicing with the OLQ eBook gives you a complete preparation ecosystem.

OLQ Ebook

Scroll to Top